Win a RootsTech Pass as We Celebrate Our YouTube Anniversary

Last year, I told my husband that I wanted to expand my dream of inspiring and educating others about genealogy and family history by cre...

21 June 2016

Should I believe the paper tree?



A few years ago, my cousin sent me some information from Germany. He had contacted a researcher in Germany and asked for some information on our Mack relatives and their friends the Puseckers.

He received a wonderful letter in response to his queries. A sweet woman spent about 7 hours looking through the Kirchenbuch for the church and seemed to have pushed our family back a few generations and supplied names for a wife we had not previously known. I was very excited to receive this information.

My first challenge was how do I document this information?
And is the letter of a person willing to do research enough 'evidence' to include these new names on my family tree? She says she looked through the Kirchenbuch and found this information. Since I'm so unfamiliar with German Genealogy, I'm stumped. I really want to be excited and claim new relatives. On the other hand, I feel a desire to have more evidence.

She had sent a handwritten tree and I typed it all into RootsMagic and started uploading the information into Ancestry and FamilySearch. But then my gut started telling me something wasn't quite right. There are no RED exclamation points on RootsMagic or FamilySearch flagging obviously errors. Things like a mothers not old enough to have children, fathers dead and children born years later. The research hasn't fallen apart in that way, but something doesn't feel right.

Pusecker tree supposedly based on Gillersheim church records, but which ones? 

And I think the trouble is what was requested and paid for by my cousin wasn't clear. If I hire someone to do German research, I need to be very explicit in what it is I want. A general looking for Mack and Pusecker in church records by someone who is familiar with the church records but not familiar with the need to documentation leaves me second-guessing. Photocopies (or pictures) of the book would have been nice so that I could verify what the researcher put together.

A quick look on the FamilySearch catalog shows that there is a Gillersheim church book for 1855-1874. Unfortunately, the one I am looking for is earlier. Guess this mystery will have to wait until another time.

6 comments:

  1. It sounds like the German "researcher" was just a kind person willing to do look-ups. A certified researcher surely would have sent more definite evidence with documentation. Wouldn't they?? The information might very well be legitimate, but you need more reassurance.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Wendy. That's what I think too. I'll treat it simply as a clue and await more supporting evidence. Isn't that what we're 'supposed' to be doing anyway?

      Delete
  2. I have lots of German ancestors, though am not an advanced genealogist when it comes to those records. The Kirchenbuch for one of my family's church's was online. Have you tried searching online? You probably have... just thought I'd throw that out there! And, in my case, it was just transcriptions. But, I was able to get the actual copies from FHL.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I know that I need to track down the Kirchenbuchs for Gillersheim for sure! Thanks for the reminder. That helps.

      Delete
  3. I'm sure it will all fit in, but you won't know the significance or detail til later.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That makes a lot of sense. I won't discount it but I look forward to someday seeing the pieces fall together. Thanks for your insight.

      Delete